Scythe, written by Neal Shusterman, is a gripping dystopian novel set in a future world where death has been conquered and humans are immortal. The story follows two teenagers, Citra and Rowan, who are chosen to apprentice as Scythes, a group of individuals responsible for “gleaning” or killing others to control the population. As the story unfolds, deep moral questions arise, making Scythe the perfect book for engaging discussions. In this article, we have compiled a list of thought-provoking Scythe discussion questions that will stimulate conversations and explore the ethical dilemmas presented in the novel.
Scythe raises many questions about the nature of mortality and the consequences of immortality. The book explores the concept of death as a necessary part of life and the implications of removing it from society. How does the absence of death affect human behavior and the value placed on life? Discuss the motivations and justifications behind the Scythes’ methods of gleaning. Do you agree with their approach or do you believe there are alternative ways to control population growth?
Another central theme in Scythe is power and corruption. The Scythes are meant to be impartial and just, but as the story progresses, we see instances of abuse of power and personal agendas. Explore the consequences of unchecked power and the potential dangers it poses. How does the presence of corruption impact the Scythedom and the society as a whole? Discuss the role of accountability and oversight in maintaining a fair and just system.
See these Scythe discussion questions
- What are the implications of a society without death?
- How does the concept of gleaning challenge our understanding of morality?
- Discuss the different approaches to gleaning presented in the book.
- What do you think of the Thunderhead’s role in the Scythedom?
- Should the Scythedom be abolished or reformed?
- Is it possible to have a fair and just system of gleaning?
- How does Scythe Faraday’s philosophy differ from other Scythes?
- What are the consequences of Scythe Faraday’s death?
- Do you believe in the concept of “gleaning quotas”? Are they effective?
- Discuss the impact of Citra and Rowan’s apprenticeship on their character development.
- What role does love play in the story? Is it a strength or a weakness?
- How does the book challenge our notions of heroism and sacrifice?
- What are the ethical dilemmas faced by Citra and Rowan throughout the story?
- Discuss the role of technology in the Scythe world. Does it enhance or hinder humanity?
- What are the consequences of the Scythedom’s secrecy?
- How does the introduction of Scythe Curie change the dynamics of the story?
- Discuss the symbolism of the Scythes’ robes and their different colors.
- What is the significance of the journal entries at the beginning of each chapter?
- Do you agree with the concept of “new order” Scythes? Why or why not?
- How does the concept of “turning a corner” impact the story?
- Discuss the role of fear in the Scythedom and how it affects the characters’ actions.
- What are the consequences of Citra and Rowan’s defiance of the Scythedom’s rules?
- How does the Thunderhead’s intervention challenge the Scythedom’s authority?
- Discuss the parallels between the Scythedom and real-world institutions of power.
- Do the Scythes have too much power? How would you limit it?
- What are the consequences of the Scythedom becoming divided?
- Discuss the role of redemption and forgiveness in the story.
- What do you think of the ending? Was it satisfying? Why or why not?
- How does Scythe challenge our perception of utopian societies?
- Discuss the impact of Citra and Rowan’s relationship on the overall plot.
- What are the consequences of Citra’s decision to become Scythe Anastasia?
- How does the story explore the concept of free will?
- Discuss the significance of the journal’s name, The Scythe’s Journal.
- What is the role of art and creativity in a deathless society?
- How does the book address the issue of gender equality?
- Discuss the implications of the Scythedom’s motto: “Kill one to save a thousand.”
- How does the story challenge our understanding of right and wrong?
- What are the consequences of the Scythedom losing sight of its original purpose?
- Discuss the impact of the Age of Mortality on the characters’ perspectives.
- How does the Thunderhead’s omniscience influence the events of the story?
- What is the role of religion in the Scythe world?
- Discuss the significance of the Scythe ring and its symbolism.
- What are the consequences of Citra and Rowan’s separation?
These Scythe discussion questions provide a starting point for in-depth conversations about the novel’s themes and their relevance to our own society. Whether you are discussing the nature of power, the complexities of morality, or the consequences of unchecked authority, Scythe offers a rich tapestry of ideas to explore. So gather your friends, book clubs, or classroom discussions and delve into the moral dilemmas presented in this thought-provoking book.
