“This Is How It Always Is” by Laurie Frankel is a thought-provoking novel that explores the complex themes of identity, family, and acceptance. The book tells the story of a family with a transgender child and the challenges they face in navigating their child’s journey. As a book club or discussion group, it’s important to delve deeper into the themes and ideas presented in the novel. To facilitate meaningful conversations, here are some discussion questions to consider.
1. How does the author portray the theme of identity throughout the novel?
2. What are some of the challenges faced by the Walsh-Adams family in understanding and supporting their transgender child?
3. Discuss the role of secrecy and disclosure in the novel. How do secrets impact the characters’ lives?
See these “This Is How It Always Is” discussion questions:
4. How does Rosie and Penn’s relationship evolve throughout the story?
5. What impact does Claude’s transition have on the family dynamics?
6. How does the author explore the theme of acceptance?
7. Discuss the different reactions of the family members and friends to Claude’s transition.
8. How does the school environment influence Claude’s experience?
9. In what ways does the media play a role in shaping public opinions about transgender individuals?
10. How does the author challenge societal norms and expectations through the character of Claude?
11. Discuss the ethical dilemmas faced by Rosie and Penn in deciding how to best support Claude.
12. What role does religion play in the novel, and how does it impact the characters’ perspectives?
13. How does the author use humor to address serious topics?
14. Discuss the significance of the title, “This Is How It Always Is.”
15. How does the novel address the importance of open communication within a family?
16. What are some of the positive and negative aspects of Claude’s experience with therapy and medical interventions?
17. Discuss the concept of gender identity versus biological sex.
18. How does the novel explore the different ways individuals express their gender?
19. What impact does Claude’s transition have on his siblings?
20. Discuss the relationship between Claude and his older brother, Roo.
21. How does the novel address the fear and uncertainty that parents may experience when their child comes out as transgender?
22. How does the character of Georgia challenge traditional gender roles and expectations?
23. Discuss the significance of storytelling and fairy tales throughout the novel.
24. How does the author address the importance of empathy and compassion in understanding transgender individuals?
25. What role does art play in the novel, and how does it help the characters express themselves?
26. Discuss the different ways in which the characters confront and overcome their own biases and prejudices.
27. How does the novel address the concept of “passing” as a particular gender?
28. What impact does Claude’s transition have on his relationship with his extended family?
29. Discuss the significance of the transgender support group in the novel.
30. How does the author address the intersectionality of gender identity and other aspects of identity, such as race or socio-economic status?
31. What are some of the challenges faced by transgender individuals in accessing healthcare and support services?
32. How does the novel explore the idea of self-acceptance and self-discovery?
33. Discuss the impact of bullying and discrimination on transgender individuals.
34. How does the novel address the concept of “normal” and challenge societal expectations?
35. What are some of the ways in which the characters in the novel demonstrate resilience and strength?
36. How does the author explore the theme of forgiveness?
37. Discuss the different parenting styles portrayed in the novel and their impact on the family.
38. What lessons can be learned from the Walsh-Adams family’s journey?
39. How does the novel address the idea of unconditional love within a family?
40. Discuss the different ways in which the characters in the novel find their own sense of happiness and fulfillment.
These discussion questions are designed to spark thoughtful conversations and encourage deeper exploration of the themes and ideas presented in “This Is How It Always Is.” Whether you are reading the book as part of a book club or engaging in a personal reflection, these questions can serve as a guide to enhance your understanding and appreciation of the novel.
